Look, I’ve been in more kitchens than I can count over the years, and this question comes up **all the time**. Stone or laminate? It’s like asking whether you want a Mercedes or a Toyota – both’ll get you where you need to go, but the journey’s gonna be different.
## The Real Deal About Stone
Stone benchtops are the real McCoy. Granite, marble, engineered stone – they’re all gorgeous, no doubt about it. You run your hand across that cool surface and you just *know* you’ve got something special.
But here’s what nobody tells you at the showroom:
– **It’s heavy.** Like, really heavy. Your cabinets better be up to the task or you’re in for a nasty surprise
– **It’s permanent.** Once it’s in, it’s IN. No changing your mind next year
– **It costs a bomb.** Not just the stone itself, but the installation, the sealing, the whole shebang
That said… man, when you’re chopping veggies on genuine stone, rolling out dough on that cool surface, there’s nothing quite like it. It’s an investment that pays you back every single day.
## Why Laminate Isn’t the Poor Cousin Anymore
Forget what you think you know about laminate. This isn’t your grandma’s kitchen counter anymore. Modern laminates? They’re **tough as nails** and some of them look so good you’d swear they were stone.
Here’s why I often recommend laminate to folks:
– **Budget-friendly** – you can get a whole kitchen done for what you’d pay for a small stone island
– **Endless options** – want wood grain? Concrete look? Marble pattern? Done, done, and done
– **Easy to live with** – no special cleaners, no yearly sealing, no worrying about that glass of red wine
– **DIY-friendly** – well, sort of. You still want a pro for the best results
## The Questions That Actually Matter
Forget the glossy brochures for a second. Here’s what you need to ask yourself:
**How long are you staying put?**
If you’re planning to sell in a couple years, laminate might make more sense. But if this is your forever home? Stone could be worth every penny.
**What’s your cooking style?**
Big Sunday dinners with hot pots everywhere? Stone handles heat like a champ. Quick weeknight meals? Laminate’s got you covered.
**Kids in the picture?**
Look, kids are… kids. They drop things. They spill things. They use benchtops as art canvases. Laminate can take a beating and if disaster strikes, it’s cheaper to replace.
**What’s your actual budget?**
And I mean your *actual* budget, not your “wouldn’t it be nice” budget. Stone installation alone can cost as much as the material itself.
## My Two Cents
After all these years, here’s what I tell people: there’s no wrong choice. I’ve seen $50,000 stone kitchens that look dated after five years, and I’ve seen laminate kitchens that still look fresh after twenty.
What matters is that it works for YOUR life. Not your neighbor’s life, not what’s trendy on Instagram, but your actual, everyday, spilling-coffee-while-rushing-to-work life.
If you’re still on the fence, here’s a thought: start with laminate. Live with it for a while. If you find yourself wishing for stone every day, you can always upgrade later. But if that laminate does everything you need and looks great doing it? Well, you just saved yourself a bundle.
End of the day, the best benchtop is the one that makes you smile when you walk into your kitchen. Stone, laminate, or carved from a meteorite – if it works for you, it’s the right choice.
—
*Need help figuring out what’s right for your Melbourne kitchen? The team at FixNow has been sorting out these decisions for years. They’ll give you the straight story, no sales pitch required.*